So i've always been really interested in the differences between rap/hip-hop music based on location. I know it's probably not as clear cut as it used to be, but WHY is the East coast so grimy compared to the cool up-beatness of Cali west coast hip-hop? Why is the south focused on producing hard music with loud beats?
This is what Wikipedia has to say:
East Coast Hip-hop
In contrast to the simplistic rhyme pattern and scheme utilized in old school hip hop, or the call and response style exhibited in the crunk genre, East Coast hip hop has been noted for its emphasis on lyrical dexterity.[2] It has also been characterized by multi-syllabic rhymes, complex wordplay, a continuous free-flowing delivery and intricate metaphors.[2] While East Coast hip hop does not have a uniform sound or standard style, it tends to gravitate to aggressive beats and sample collages.[1] The aggressive and hard-hitting beats of the form were emphasized by such acts as EPMD and Public Enemy, while artists such as Eric B. & Rakim, Boogie Down Productions, and Slick Rick were noted for their lyrical skill.
This is what I consider to be a perfect example of East Coast hip-hop. The beat is grimy and in a way I guess you could describe east coast hip-hop as fairly aggressive.
West Coast Hip-hop
West Coast rap in a new direction,[26] influenced strongly by P funk artists, melding sleazy funk beats with slowly drawled lyrics. This came to be known as G-funk and dominated mainstream hip hop for several years through a roster of artists on Death Row Records including Snoop Dogg, whose Doggystyle included the songs "What's My Name" and "Gin and Juice," both top ten hits.
That right there is the exact definition of a G-funk beat. Dr. Dre really turned the West Coast around and added some individuality to the state of Cali. The beat is just so much more up-beat and "hell yeah lets party to this" instead of the Grimy east raps where you're like "man fuck the government!"
.... ....
And it doesn't even stop there, you've got the south and the midwest both forming their own styles throughout history.... Now days the differences arn't so clear cut unless you're into the underground stuff. The south pretty much dominates, but there are still west and east coast rappers who stick to the roots.
People like Eminem in the midwest arn't so clear cut because of the range of differences between artists like Bone Thugs and Tech N9ne but for the most part the Midwest was derived on fast paced songs with darker beats.
Found this quote thought it was interesting...
One characteristic of Midwest hip hop is that beat tempos can range from 90 to about 180, while East Coast's beat tempo is 90-120, West Coast is 100-120, and Southern rap is 80-110
7:43 pm on Sep. 1, 2009 | Joined: Jan. 2007 | Days Active: 715 Join to learn more about 420mikeMichigan, United States | Posts: 15,160 | Points: 37,706
LiveWire Humor
ViLE
Soothsayer Patron
West coast rap FTW.
------- Also...
Go Die.
7:44 pm on Sep. 1, 2009 | Joined: Aug. 2007 | Days Active: 194 Join to learn more about ViLEEngland, United Kingdom | GayMale | Posts: 14,430 | Points: 13,627
Cyanotype
≈ Sustainer Support Leader Tech Support Leader
People in the south tend to dance a lot. I mean we bounce.
West coast people are laid back, as is their music.
East coast rappers get to business and don't sugar anything.
nice post mike i was just exploring all of this a few weeks ago its interesting i agree
------- give me a paper & pen so i can write about my life of sin
7:45 pm on Sep. 1, 2009 | Joined: Mar. 2005 | Days Active: 1,482 Join to learn more about SkipOntario, Canada | MetrosexualMale | Posts: 35,201 | Points: 50,317
Exactly. I just started taking this social psychology course and it made me think about this. The music is definitely formed based on social influence of their environment. The east is hard, cold, straight to business. Where like you said, the west is laid back, chill. It's just really cool how that works.
7:47 pm on Sep. 1, 2009 | Joined: Jan. 2007 | Days Active: 715 Join to learn more about 420mikeMichigan, United States | Posts: 15,160 | Points: 37,706
Trendz
Scenester Sustainer Tech Support Leader
East coast is my thing. Southern music FTL.. It's such trash..
8:42 pm on Sep. 1, 2009 | Joined: Oct. 2008 | Days Active: 308 Join to learn more about TrendzOntario, Canada | Posts: 19,195 | Points: 37,873
Exactly. I just started taking this social psychology course and it made me think about this. The music is definitely formed based on social influence of their environment. The east is hard, cold, straight to business. Where like you said, the west is laid back, chill. It's just really cool how that works.
That's a good observation! I do see the trend.
8:43 pm on Sep. 1, 2009 | Joined: Oct. 2008 | Days Active: 308 Join to learn more about TrendzOntario, Canada | Posts: 19,195 | Points: 37,873
TBMP
Soothsayer Patron
i like the west coast better, but east coast rap gets my vote almost every time. I'm big on the Philly scene, namely, but even in the midde-ish united states rap is mostly better than here (common, for example, the chicago beast) the west coast rappers tend to dumb it down a lot, and while i see the appeal that doesn't mean i buy into it.
11:15 pm on Sep. 1, 2009 | Joined: Sep. 2008 | Days Active: 276 Join to learn more about TBMPCalifornia, United States | BisexualMale | Posts: 7,414 | Points: 12,124
SpRiNgS
only man to ever DDT the pope Patron Support Leader
pretty much nailed it actually
------- pressure becomes real only the moment we acknowledge that it can affect us
10:06 am on Sep. 2, 2009 | Joined: July 2005 | Days Active: 1,312 Join to learn more about SpRiNgSHonduras | StraightMale | Posts: 43,464 | Points: 57,581
Sudo XE
Guru
look at the people that make up those regions.
A lot of people don't own cars in New York - but there is a distinctive car culture in many areas of the south. Someone put it to me like this - NY rappers make music for the ipod - music that you're supposed to sit and think about on the train; southern rappers make music for the car - where the beat is SUPPOSED to overshadow the emcee. So in the north, the beat is largely irrelevant when compared to the rapper - while in the South, the beat and the emcee are co-partners or extensions of each other.
This is why people often complain that NY rappers have terrible beat selection, and that Southern rappers lack lyrical ability and are carried by their beats.
And then the musical styles that were popular in these regions when they made their emergence onto the rap scene is also important - look at the history of crunk, g-funk, and so forth - all based in different musical traditions found in their respective regions
1:00 pm on Sep. 2, 2009 | Joined: Feb. 2007 | Days Active: 862 Join to learn more about Sudo XESouth Carolina, United States | StraightMale | Posts: 11,964 | Points: 21,841
A lot of people don't own cars in New York - but there is a distinctive car culture in many areas of the south. Someone put it to me like this - NY rappers make music for the ipod - music that you're supposed to sit and think about on the train; southern rappers make music for the car - where the beat is SUPPOSED to overshadow the emcee. So in the north, the beat is largely irrelevant when compared to the rapper - while in the South, the beat and the emcee are co-partners or extensions of each other.
This is why people often complain that NY rappers have terrible beat selection, and that Southern rappers lack lyrical ability and are carried by their beats.
And then the musical styles that were popular in these regions when they made their emergence onto the rap scene is also important - look at the history of crunk, g-funk, and so forth - all based in different musical traditions found in their respective regions
I agree with this. For the majority, the best music to bump to is the stupidest, lyric-wise.
------- Hi, my name is- You won't remember... S » G
1:06 pm on Sep. 2, 2009 | Joined: June 2008 | Days Active: 373 Join to learn more about Clara BellNorth Carolina, United States | StraightFemale | Posts: 23,149 | Points: 28,045
Lambo Girl
Advisor
I dont eally care i just like CB
------- I Will Not Let Sex Be Detrimental To My Sucess
2:44 pm on Sep. 2, 2009 | Joined: July 2009 | Days Active: 37 Join to learn more about Lambo GirlDelaware, United States | StraightFemale | Posts: 55 | Points: 431
A lot of people don't own cars in New York - but there is a distinctive car culture in many areas of the south. Someone put it to me like this - NY rappers make music for the ipod - music that you're supposed to sit and think about on the train; southern rappers make music for the car - where the beat is SUPPOSED to overshadow the emcee. So in the north, the beat is largely irrelevant when compared to the rapper - while in the South, the beat and the emcee are co-partners or extensions of each other.
This is why people often complain that NY rappers have terrible beat selection, and that Southern rappers lack lyrical ability and are carried by their beats.
And then the musical styles that were popular in these regions when they made their emergence onto the rap scene is also important - look at the history of crunk, g-funk, and so forth - all based in different musical traditions found in their respective regions
Truth
6:51 pm on Sep. 2, 2009 | Joined: Jan. 2007 | Days Active: 715 Join to learn more about 420mikeMichigan, United States | Posts: 15,160 | Points: 37,706