Why not make your own game with him? I guarantee it will be better than anything you get at Spencer's. To make the game, both of you should write down sexual favors on small slips of paper. Write ones you want to do to each other, and ones you want them to do to you. Put them all in a bowl. Put the ones for you on pink paper and the ones for him on blue. You can make it as wild or tame as you want, plus you can push your boundaries and show your partner what you really like.
To play: play poker or blackjack or any other game where there is a winner right away. The loser has to pick a card for the other person and perform that favor.